"Horstachio of a Different Color" is the sixth episode of Viva Piñata's first season. It aired in North America on September 9, 2006.
Hamilton Horstachio, Mabel Moozipan, Hudson Horstachio, Fergy Fudgehog, Franklin Fizzlybear, and Paulie Pretztail are hanging out at Hudson's House, talking about the upcoming spring fair Horstachio competition. Simone bursts through the door and alerts Hudson that he is losing all his bookings to a new Horstachio named Hamilton. Hudson's friends reassure him that he will win though. After a brief encounter with Mabel, Fergy, Franklin, and Paulie head over to the Doflap Inn and find out from Pecky that Hamilton is the real deal. Suddenly Hamilton enters the building, surrounded by the Pudgeon press corps. The cocky piñata then slips into the bathroom, where he secretly cancels some of Hudson's parties, however Fergy, Paulie, and Franklin overhear him! They devise a plan of their own to sabotage Hamiliton for the spring fair. Meanwhile, Simone tries in vain to get Hudson into shape for the fair.
Hudson finally begins to train after seeing the gang hanging out with Hamilton. Meanwhile, the piñatas have been sabotaging Hamilton's chances by keeping him from eating and sleeping. When he is finally left in Mabel's garden to rest, he wakes up famished and devours her blackberries and daisies. In the morning, the Spring fair has started. Hudson shows up at the last minute and appears to be the victor, until Hamilton appears, transformed into a Zumbug. Hamilton is pronounced the winner and things seem over for Hudson. Mabel dashes up, blurting out that Hamilton ate the daisies and blackberries in her garden, changing him into a Zumbug. Since it is a Horstachio contest, Hamilton is disqualified and Hudson is declared the winner!
- When a Quackberry eats Gooseberries, it turns into a Juicygoose.
- When a Horstachio eats Blackberries and Daisies, it turns into a Zumbug.
- Paulie: Now I know what a toasted marshmallow feels like.
- Franklin: Mmm... I'm yummy.
- Hudson: I think I dislocated my eyebrow.
- Mabel: Feel the wrath of my giant hoe, garden wrecker!
- Paulie: Sign my friend?
- Fergy and Paulie are shown standing together, but when they get burnt Paulie is suddenly next to Franklin.
- Sometimes Fergy's hump is shorter, rounder and fluffier than usual.
Characters which make their first appearances in this episode are: